MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

524 views

Explain and illustrate two reasons for holding the view that at birth the mind is a tabula rasa (blank slate). [15 marks]

What is a tabula rasa?

The empiricists held that humans are born as blank slates. This means that there are no 'innate ideas' -- ideas possessed at birth, prior to any experience. Locke used the analogy that the mind is a blank piece of paper, and that experience is what writes symbols on it.

HUME'S ARGUMENTS:

1. A blind man can never grasp the idea of the colour red. This shows that ideas are derived from experience. It follows that at birth, prior to experience, we would have no ideas -- we would be 'blank slates'.

This observation is plausible. It provides an example of the view that ideas have their "origins in the senses", and that without those senses we would not have any ideas.

However, Hume needs to establish that this holds for all of our ideas. Someone could consistently accept that the idea of red must be derived from sensation (and hence would not be present at birth), but deny that this held for all sensations. For example, it is not obvious that the ideas of God, the soul or power are derived from the senses, so generalising from one example is unconvincing.

2. Hume issues the challenge to produce an idea that is not derived from experience. He argues that no such examples are to be found, and hence there are no counter-examples to the claim that all ideas are derived from sensation. This would have the consequence that we possess no ideas at birth, prior to having experience, and would hence be blank slates.

If Hume is right to hold that there are no counter-examples to be found, then this would indeed vindicate the view that the mind is a 'tabula rasa' at birth. However, there are some weaknesses in the way he argues: he relies on empiricist accounts of e.g. the idea of God; he accepts the possibility of having an idea of a "missing shade of blue", which would be a counter-example; and he appeals to his doctrine that all ideas are derived from experience to deny that we have any idea of "occult qualities" -- this seems circular.

James H. GCSE Philosophy tutor, A Level Philosophy tutor, Mentoring P...

1 year ago

Answered by James, an A Level Philosophy tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

15 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£22 /hr

Rachelle O.

Degree: Spanish and Philosophy (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered: Philosophy, Spanish+ 4 more

Philosophy
Spanish
Religious Studies
Philosophy and Ethics
Biology
-Personal Statements-

“About Me:Hello there! My name is Rachelle Ojomo and I am a first year undergraduate studyingSpanish and Philosophy at the University of Durham. I am incredibly passionate and enthusiastic about these two subjects and hope that after ...”

£20 /hr

Oliver W.

Degree: Philosophy (Bachelors) - Warwick University

Subjects offered: Philosophy, English Literature+ 2 more

Philosophy
English Literature
English Language

“About Me: Hi! My name is Oli. I’m a current undergraduate studying Philosophy at the University of Warwick. My life is a concoction of academic interests, but language, literature and their philosophical applications are at the forefr...”

£20 /hr

Katya P.

Degree: Religion and Theology (Bachelors) - Bristol University

Subjects offered: Philosophy, Religious Studies+ 2 more

Philosophy
Religious Studies
History
Extended Project Qualification

“A bit about me: I'm Katya and I'm in my first year studying Religion and Theology at the University of Bristol. As you can guess from my degree title, my passion is for religious studies, but I'm also keen to tutor in History, Philoso...”

About the author

James H.

Currently unavailable: for regular students

Degree: Philosophy (Doctorate) - Cambridge University

Subjects offered: Philosophy, Philosophy and Ethics+ 1 more

Philosophy
Philosophy and Ethics
-Personal Statements-

“Enthusiastic, high-flying Oxford and Cambridge graduate. Eager to help you achieve your potential in German and Philosophy!”

You may also like...

Posts by James

Explain and illustrate two reasons for holding the view that at birth the mind is a tabula rasa (blank slate). [15 marks]

Was konnte man sich lange Zeit nicht vorstellen? Warum? [2 marks]

Other A Level Philosophy questions

Explain Hume’s Argument Against Miracles

Explain and illustrate two reasons for holding the view that at birth the mind is a tabula rasa (blank slate). [15 marks]

What is the ‘hard problem’ of consciousness?

What is compatibilism?

View A Level Philosophy tutors

Cookies:

We use cookies to improve our service. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok