Should prisoners be given the right to vote?

Yes:Disenfranchisement increases prisoners sense of separation from society. Therefore increases anti-social behaviour.Conversely, enfranchisement (see, e.g., Tocqueville) encourages citizens to look beyond their own interests to the interest of society. Therefore encourages pro-social behaviour.A fundamental right as a citizen is to have a say in who governs. If we deny the right to vote, we deny that prisoners are citizens, therefore why do we have the right to imprison them?
No:They have demonstrated that they are not fully capable members of society. We are therefore justified in removing some of the rights of full capable members of society, including the right to vote.The prisoners' vote represents a dangerous voting base. It might encourage niche politicians to pander to the interests of prisoners.Prison is supposed to be a punishment – part of that punishment is the removal of the right to vote.
Structure:IntroductionShort, two or three sentences. Which side do you support, with maybe a one-line summary of your strongest argument.Main sectionFirst reasonReason, with some substantiation, followed by an example.Second reasonReason, with some substantiation, followed by an example.[Third reason, depending on how much time you have]Counter exampleConsider a counter briefly, and then say why this doesn't defeat your case.ConclusionSummarise arguments, conclude with something pithy if you can think of something.Summarise main reasons,

DS
Answered by David S. TSA Oxford tutor

5500 Views

See similar TSA Oxford University tutors

Related TSA Oxford University answers

All answers ▸

Every year in Britain there are nearly 25 000 car fires, yet it is estimated that only five per cent of motorists...Which of the following is the best statement of the flaw in the argument above?


“Is “Ethical” Consumerism A Solution To Poverty, Or A Dangerous Distraction?”


Every year 1000 people fall off their boats into the water, yet some boats still do not carry life jackets. If all boats did carry life jackets then the number of people falling into the water would be reduced. What is the flaw in this argument?


How should I structure a Section 2 answer in the Oxford TSA?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2025

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences