MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

3334 views

How do you answer a ‘how far do you agree with the statement’ question?

This type of question can come up in both GCSE and A-Level History papers. Firstly, it is important to show both sides of the argument- you must outline points which both support and those which challenge the statement you’ve been given. The arguments you make must be supported with in-depth, developed historical knowledge and when appropriate, other people’s interpretations of history. You must consistently analyse both your own knowledge and any other interpretations you include. You should have a sustained argument throughout, which you should first outline in your introduction. To ensure you give both sides of the debate but keep your own argument sustained, you should outline the weaknesses of the opposing arguments, showing how your argument in ultimately stronger than the others. Your conclusion should not be a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer but, as the question suggests, should focus on ‘how far’- consider using expressions such as ‘to some extent’ to show the examiner that you understand what the question is asking you. You could also consider breaking up the question: the example below is asking you to cover the years 1958 to 1969, but by breaking up this time period as has been done in the example below, you can demonstrate to the examiner a certain depth of knowledge and understanding of your period.

An example of an introduction to a ‘how far’ question to do with the Cold War is shown below to illustrate these points:

‘Sino-Soviet relations, in the years 1958-69, were undermined primarily by conflicting national interests’. How far do you agree with this view? 

It seems likely that between 1958 and 1964 (breaking up the time period), Sino-Soviet relations were undermined by the personal rivalry which existed between Mao and Khrushchev rather than national interests. These personal rivalries made meetings unproductive and led Mao to act in a way that the USSR could have perceived as overconfident, raising tensions. However, from 1964, when Khrushchev was disposed of, Sino-Soviet relations appear to have been undermined by problems arising from conflicting national interests. For example, the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968, which arguably stemmed from national interests, may have been interpreted by China as a clear message that the Communist world had to adhere to Soviet ideas, which they could have found quite threatening, undermining their relationship (historical knowledge followed by analysis). Nevertheless, it is also possible that Sino-Soviet relations were undermined in some minor ways by ideological differences in these years as they could have confirmed to the USSR that China was no longer under their influence. Nevertheless, a closer examination reveals that ideological problems were underpinned by personal rivalries (points to other arguments but shows why their own is ultimately stronger, ensuring their argument is sustained). Therefore, overall, it seems most probable that Sino-Soviet relations were, to a great degree, undermined by personal rivalries between 1958 and 1964. However, from 1964, the view that Sino-Soviet relations were undermined by conflicting national interests seems to have been accurate to a significant extent (answers ‘how far’)

Ella  H. A Level History tutor, 13 plus  History tutor, GCSE History ...

1 year ago

Answered by Ella , an A Level History tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

81 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£20 /hr

Benjamin D.

Degree: History and Politics (Bachelors) - Oxford, Brasenose College University

Subjects offered:History, English Literature+ 1 more

History
English Literature
.HAT.

“Consistent A* student of History and Politics at Oxford University tutoring in History and English. Friendly, Patient and Informative tutoring style.”

£20 /hr

Samuel Z.

Degree: History (Bachelors) - York University

Subjects offered:History, Maths+ 3 more

History
Maths
Extended Project Qualification
English Literature
-Personal Statements-

“About Me Hello! My name is Sam and I am reading a BA in History at the University of York. In May 2013 I graduated with 44 point on my International Baccalaureate and so I know the IB. I know how to beat exams and how to maximise the ...”

£26 /hr

Luthien C.

Degree: Applied Human Rights (Masters) - York University

Subjects offered:History, German+ 1 more

History
German
English Literature

“About me: Hi! My name is Luthien and I am currently working towards a Masters degree in Applied Human Rights at the University of York. I have a Bachelors degree in History and German from the University of Durham (First Class Honours...”

About the author

£22 /hr

Ella H.

Degree: History with a European Language (Bachelors) - University College London University

Subjects offered:History, Spanish+ 3 more

History
Spanish
Extended Project Qualification
English Literature
-Personal Statements-

“About MeI completed my A-Levels in History, Spanish and English Literature in 2015 and now study History with Spanish at University College London. I am passionate about all three subjects and havea wide range of knowledge about them...”

You may also like...

Other A Level History questions

Assess the reasons why Westward Expansion caused frictions between Northern and Southern States in the US during the 1850's.

‘The Brezhnev era was a period of stagnation and dissent, despite appearances to the contrary.’ Assess the validity of this view (45 marks)

How do you write a good essay under exam conditions?

How should I approach revision?

View A Level History tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok