Should the House of Lords be elected?

It could be argued that, yes, the House of Lords should be elected because it would make parliament more democratic. One may suggest that an unelected chamber has no place in a modern democracy therefore needs to be changed. Also, the current method of selecting Lords could be deemed wholly unfair (especially given the recent 'cash for honours' scandel in 2007). As well as this, it would give the public greater representation, possibly more access points to the government and more chance for political participation - hence enhacing our democracy. On the other hand, however, an elected House of Lords may cause problems. These potential problems are proven in the USA, who currently have two elected chambers, and include gridlock. This means that, as both houses are elected, it's harder to force legislation upon the other - leading to a slower legislation process. As well as this, we would risk implementing a 'democratic overload' on the public which may lead to lower turnout and therefore a less democratic state overall. It can also be argued that the current Lords are specialists in their field and therefore putting this decision to the public may lead to a loss of this expertise as they wouldn't understand who is best equipped for the job.

AD
Answered by Amelia D. Government and Politics tutor

16100 Views

See similar Government and Politics A Level tutors

Related Government and Politics A Level answers

All answers ▸

Explain the main criticisms that have been made of the World Trade Organization. (15 marks)


Examine the view that the House of Lords is an outdated institution, and should be abolished or replaced


'An 18th century process still used for the election of the 21st century president.' Critically evaluate this view of the Electoral College. (30 marks)


To what extent can Congress be considered the ‘broken branch’ of government? (45 Marks)


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2025

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences