Five point charges, each of positive charge q, are arranged to form the corners of a uniform pentagon. A point charge Q is placed at the pentagon's centre. One of the corner charges is removed. What force does the centre charge experience?

There are four keys to answering this problem - when taken together, they turn a seemingly difficult calculation into a trivial one-line answer. The first is knowing Coulomb's inverse square law for the force between two point charges. The second is drawing a diagram of the system described in the question - first with all the charges, then with one removed. The third is understanding that electric forces come from electric fields, and that electric fields can be superposed, so the total field at the centre comes from adding the fields from each individual charge. The fourth, and hardest, step comes from considering the symmetry of the system.Solution: draw diagram (I will draw by hand during session). Clearly when all the charges are present, the net force in any direction is zero, by symmetry. We orient the system so that one of the corner charges is vertically above the centre on the page (this is just to make things easier to visualise) and call this the y direction. Then we remove that charge. If this charge were the only charge present, then the total force on the centre charge would be given by Coulomb's law between that charge and the centre charge; call that force F, along the y direction (F = -qQ/(4pipermittivity of free space*d2), where d is the distance from the centre to the corner). But the total force with all 5 charges present is zero. So by superposition, we know that the force from the other four charges must be minus F in the y direction. This is the final answer - and we worked it out without having to do any calculation, just applying relevant physical principles.

TA
Answered by Theo A. PAT tutor

2314 Views

See similar PAT University tutors

Related PAT University answers

All answers ▸

A function is defined piecewise f(x) = ( e^x for x<0, e^(-x) + 2x for x>= 0). Sketch f(x) and its first, second and third derivatives


How do I sketch a function from its equation without using my graphical calculator?


Given that during a total solar eclipse the Sun is fully hidden by the Moon, calculate the radius of the Moon. (You may use the following: Solar radius 700,000 km, Sun-Earth distance 150,000,000 km, Moon-Earth distance 400,000 km)


Estimate the radius of the moon based on a solar eclipse given the distances between the earth and the moon, the earth and the sun, and the radius of the sun.


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2025

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences