"Freud simply misunderstood religious belief" Evaluate this view (30 marks)

To those without faith, certainly some aspects of religion and religious belief seem outdated and with the advancements in the fields of psychology, alternative explanations for religious belief have emerged. Freud did this in his work "Totem and Taboo", "The Future of an Illusion", and "Civilisation and it's Discontents" but has come under criticism as having missed the point and misinterpreted religious belief throughout parts of his work.One suggestion he makes is that religious belief is an "infantile response" to the need for a 'father figure' as well as to address our eschatological issues. This could perhaps be too simplistic when faced with the overwhelming examples of great Christian theologians and philosophers who's faith directly influenced them. One such theologian is Thomas Aquinas- Freud's claims seem insubstantial against this as Aquinas' arguments for the existence of God do not necessarily seem to be an "infantile response". Therefor, it could be suggested that Freud ignored the intellectual aspect to faith and the idea that religious belief can provoke philosophical questioning in a framework beyond something child-like.

KU
Answered by Katie U. Religious Studies tutor

5058 Views

See similar Religious Studies A Level tutors

Related Religious Studies A Level answers

All answers ▸

What is William James' argument in the "Will to Believe" (in reference to the topic "religious experience")?


How do I incorporate enough scholarly comment to back up my analytical essays?


Explain two different views on the death penalty in modern society with reference to religious beliefs. (4 marks)


Explain the significance of the Golden Mean in relation to Aristotle's Virtue Theory ?


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

MyTutor is part of the IXL family of brands:

© 2026 by IXL Learning