Explain the Gillick Principle

The Gillick Principle orginates from the House of Lords case, Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority) [1986]. A mother, who was a devout Catholics and didn’t believe in contraception, took her local health authority to court to prevent her underage teenage girls going to a GP and getting contracpetion. This was in response to a Department of Health letter to GPs which stated if an underage girl was mature enough, they should be given contracpetion.

The House of Lords held the letter from the department of health was valid advice. Lord Fraser introduced a checklist for whether a child under 16 should be given contraception.

Lord Fraser's checklist:

    1) girl will understand advice

    2) cannot be persuaded to inform parents 

    3) likely to begin/continue intercourse with or without contraception

    4) without contraception, physical and mental health likely to suffer

    5) best interests require contraception without parental consent

Lord Scarman provided a wider test, and is more appropiate for establishing when a child gain autonomy in a wider context. He suggests using the maturity to establish whhether a child has autonomy but suggests it must be used carefully.

 “A child is competent once acquires "sufficient understanding and intelligence to enable him or her to understand fully what is proposed.”

James R. GCSE Law tutor, A Level Law tutor, Uni Admissions Test .LNAT...

4 months ago

Answered by James, an A Level Law tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist


Alice M. GCSE Psychology tutor, A Level Psychology tutor, A Level Law...
View profile
£20 /hr

Alice M.

Degree: BSci Psychology (Bachelors) - Birmingham University

Subjects offered: Law, Psychology


“Hello, I'm Alice! I am currently in my second year of studying Psychology at Birmingham ”

PremiumAlexander K. GCSE Law tutor, A Level Law tutor, IB Russian tutor, GCS...
View profile
£22 /hr

Alexander K.

Degree: MSc in Taxation (Masters) - Oxford, Kellogg College University

Subjects offered: Law, Russian+ 1 more

-Personal Statements-

“About me I am currently studying a postgraduate degree in Tax Law at the University of Oxford. I am looking forward to teaching you Law!  Law is full of hidden depths and is probably one of the most fascinating subjects out there (tho...”

PremiumWilliam A. A Level Law tutor, GCSE Law tutor, A Level Economics tutor...
View profile
£30 /hr

William A.

Degree: Law (Bachelors) - Cambridge alumni University

Subjects offered: Law, Maths+ 3 more


“I recently graduated from the University of Cambridge in Law and completed my A Levels in 2012 with 4 A*s in Maths, Economics, Physics and Chemistry.I am a friendly and approachable person and have previously tutored A Level Econom...”

About the author

James R. GCSE Law tutor, A Level Law tutor, Uni Admissions Test .LNAT...
View profile
£20 /hr

James R.

Degree: Law (Bachelors) - Bristol University

Subjects offered: Law, History+ 3 more

English Literature
English Language

“About Me  I recently graduated from Bristol University with a Law Degree and I am currently studying the Legal Practice Course at the University of Law. I have always cherished the ‘humanities’ and hope I can help others enjoy them ...”

MyTutor guarantee

You may also like...

Posts by James

1. Describe the main features of the doctrine of precedent

Explain the Gillick Principle

Other A Level Law questions

Should Law reflect morality? (very short answer for 40 mark essay)

What is the difference between Actus Reus and Mens Rea?

Should the law of murder be reformed within the UK?

What are some good ways to learn the law for AS and A2?

View A Level Law tutors


We use cookies to improve our service. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss