Why might we suggest religious language is meaningless?

The view that religious language is meaningless is most associated with A. J. Ayer and his theory of verificationism. Ayer posited that there is a general test (the verification principle) that can test whether a specific statement has meaning. When he applies this test to religious statements, he argues that they fail the test and are therefore meaningless. The verification principle is as follows - 'a statement is held to be literally meaningful if and only if it is either analytic or empirically verifiable.' (Note: this is a revised version of an earlier principle that Ayer laid out.) So - a statement has meaning if it is a) analytic, meaning it is true just by the meanings of the words - 'All bachelors are unmarried' is an example of this, or b) empirically verifiable, meaning we could observe empirical evidence which would establish the truth of the statement.
Let's now apply this to a religious statement, such as 'God exists.' Does this pass Ayer's test for meaning? Firstly, is it analytic? Ayer argues no - it is not part of the meaning of 'God' that he exists. Secondly, is it empirically verifiable? Again, Ayer argues no. God is part of a 'transcendent' metaphysical reality that exists outside our realm of sense experience. Therefore, there is no possible experience we could have, or observation we could make, which would establish the truth of the statement.

AW
Answered by Ashley W. Religious Studies tutor

2267 Views

See similar Religious Studies A Level tutors

Related Religious Studies A Level answers

All answers ▸

Explain the approach to proving the existence of God taken by Anselm’s ontological argument.


What is the doctrine of the Trinity?


Why is Evil a problem


(a) Outline Sallie McFague’s responses to the view that God is male. [25]


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

© MyTutorWeb Ltd 2013–2025

Terms & Conditions|Privacy Policy
Cookie Preferences