MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

743 views

Why is Milgram's experiment on obedience considered so unethical?

Despite no real physical harm to the participant nor the confederate, Milgram's 1963 experiment broke the code of conduct in regard to what constitutes an ethical study in a number of ways, and if presented today, Milgram would likely not gain the approval to carry out his study in the first place. The first issue was that Milgram used deception; he thought this to be necessary to help meet his aims in a valid way, and although some levels of deception are sometimes acceptable, in this case not disclosing the true nature of the study led to further issues. Due to this, full informed consent could not be gained and only in a debrief were participants told that the study was not about intelligence, but rather the effects of authority on obedience. However, throughout and some time after the experiment, several participants experiences psychological harm as they believed they were seriously harming an individual, and later felt sever guilt that just because they instructed, they would in fact administer fatal electric shocks to another human being. Moreover, psychological conduct states that participants should be allowed a right to withdrawm from a study at any given time, however in this experiment, whenever the participant expressed signs of distress and wanting to quit, they were urged to continue by the 'scientist' until they continued, with only a small minority not seeing the experiment all the way to the end. Therefore, even though participants did not experience any pain or long-term damage, they were not put in a position where they could give full informed consent, were placed in highly stressful situations and found difficulty in withdraing from such circumstances, making this one of the most unethical experiments in psychological history. 

Serena S. GCSE English tutor, 11 Plus English tutor, A Level English ...

11 months ago

Answered by Serena, an A Level Psychology tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

37 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£36 /hr

Jessica-Lily H.

Degree: MRes Experimental Neuroscience (Masters) - Imperial College London University

Subjects offered:Psychology, Biology

Psychology
Biology

“Top tutor from a world leading university- ready to do all I can to help you get your head around that tricky subject!”

£26 /hr

Katherine W.

Degree: Psychology (Foundations in Clinical and Forensic Psychology) (Masters) - Newcastle University

Subjects offered:Psychology, Philosophy and Ethics

Psychology
Philosophy and Ethics

“Psychology MSc Student with experience at Psychology GCSE and A-level as well as RS GCSE and A-level. Prior Teaching experience. Full DBS Certificate.”

MyTutor guarantee

£20 /hr

Nina S.

Degree: Psychology (Bachelors) - York University

Subjects offered:Psychology, Maths+ 1 more

Psychology
Maths
French

“Psychology student at the University of York with a passion for biological mechanisms and their effect on behaviour”

About the author

Serena S.

Currently unavailable: for new students

Degree: Education (Bachelors) - Birmingham University

Subjects offered:Psychology, Sociology+ 1 more

Psychology
Sociology
English

“I am a current third year student at the University of Birmingham. I take a patient and somewhat fun approach to teaching as to not make it seem like 'extra school' but instead learning that the student wants to partake in, and have n...”

Trusted by schools

|  21 completed tutorials

You may also like...

Other A Level Psychology questions

What are the clinical characteristics of Schizophrenia?

Discuss the strengths of conducting a laboratory experiment.

How should I structure my essays?

What is a limitation of research into cultural variations in attachment?

View A Level Psychology tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok