MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

402 views

What is Olbers' paradox?

Olbers' paradox is a thought experiment that arises in cosmology* which shows that our universe does not fit the "Static Newtonian" model.

Sir Isaac Newton came up with a model for the universe which can be described by four basic statements:

i) The universe is infinitely large

ii) The universe is infinitely old

iii) The universe is not expanding or contracting (i.e. it is "static")

iv) All the planets, stars, galaxies etc. are roughly evenly distributed throughout the universe (i.e. it has "large-scale homogeneity")

This came to be referred to as the Static Newtonian model.

Olbers' paradox is a logical argument which attempts to show that our universe cannot fit this model. It does this by arguing the following:

If the universe was infinitely large, and had a fairly even distribution of stars throughout it, then this would mean that there would be an infinite number of stars surrounding the Earth on all sides. Furthermore, if this universe was infinitely old, then the light from all of those stars would have had enough time to reach the Earth. With an infinite amount of stars on all sides, constantly emitting an infinite amount of light, our sky would always be infinitely bright - there would be no difference between day and night. This is obviously not the case!

We can see that our four statements have lead us to a model that does not agree with our observation that the sky is dark at night. Therefore at least one, or possibly several of these statements must be false. This leads us to the following conclusions: either,

a) the universe is finite in size, and thus has a finite number of stars

b) the universe has some finite age, and thus the light from most stars has not had enough time to reach us

c) the stars, planets etc. are not evenly spread on a large scale, which would also allow for a finite number of stars

d) some combination of a), b) and c).

These conclusions lead us to consider more sophisticated models of the universe, such as the Big Bang model, which states that a) and b) are true, but not c): i.e. the universe is expanding (and therefore not static, unlike Newton's model).

 

 

*The study of our universe; its structure, how it changes with time, how it began, etc.

Alexander J. IB Physics tutor, A Level Physics tutor, GCSE Physics tu...

2 years ago

Answered by Alexander, an IB Physics tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

6 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£22 /hr

Jonas P.

Degree: MPhys Theoretical Physics (Bachelors) - Edinburgh University

Subjects offered: Physics, Maths

Physics
Maths

“I am currently a student at the University of Edinburgh, doing my 4th year of the MPhys Theoretical Physics programme. I've managed to score an average grade of 81% in year 3, and I tend to consistently do well in my exams, which I be...”

£20 /hr

Rudolfs G.

Degree: Physics BSc (Bachelors) - Manchester University

Subjects offered: Physics, Maths+ 1 more

Physics
Maths
Economics

“Hi, my name is Rudolfs and I'm a second year Physics student at the University of Manchester. I'm currently expected to achieve a 1st and I've achieved 41 points in the International Baccalaureate, therefore I believe that I am capabl...”

£22 /hr

Rudolfs T.

Degree: Physics with Theoretical Physics (Masters) - Manchester University

Subjects offered: Physics, Maths

Physics
Maths

“I am a theoretical physics student at the University of Manchester. Even though I'm only in my first year I've had a lot of interaction with science already. I have participated and obtained medals in the International Physics Olympia...”

About the author

Alexander J.

Currently unavailable: for new students

Degree: Natural Sciences (Physical) (Bachelors) - Cambridge University

Subjects offered: Physics, Maths

Physics
Maths

“Third year Astrophysicist - keen to help with any level of Maths or Physics!”

You may also like...

Posts by Alexander

What is integration by parts, and how is it useful?

What is Olbers' paradox?

Other IB Physics questions

Why is centripetal acceleration directed inwards to the centre of the circle during centripetal motion? If I’m in a car while it’s cornering, I seem to be pushed outwards away from the centre, not inwards.

Based on Newton's 3 laws of motion why is linear momentum always conserved?

Alternating current produced by the generator in a nuclear power plant is supplied to the primary coil of a transformer. Explain, with reference to Faraday's law of electromagnetic induction, how a current arises in the secondary coil.

What is Olbers' paradox?

View IB Physics tutors

Cookies:

We use cookies to improve our service. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok