MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

890 views

To what extent can Othello's ending be described as 'self inflicted'?

To get top marks in a question like this, when you are writing your paragraphs, you must include three things, which are; citing references from all across the book to show you've read all of it and not just one bit, critical commentary and lastly contextual discussion. To explain my answer I shall pop quotations in directly as necessary, but know that in a real answer you should explain why you are including them, by saying something like, 'and to demonstrate this point, Othello's statement that ...'

Firstly, we may talk about how his ending is indeed self inflicted. Othello himself admits that he is a jealous creature, and he was letting the emotion get the better of him. 'The green-eye'd monster that doth mock me'. Furthermore, throughout the play, Othello's constant need for proof alludes to the fact that he is much more jealous than he is letting on: 'I'll see before I doubt;when I doubt, prove; I and on that proof, there is no more but this'. Indeed, in the end, Othello is the one who proclaims his own guilt; 'Twas I that killed her'. T.S. Eliot called this mounting of jealousy a 'terrible exposure of human weakness'. Thus, his own jealously that he lets grab a hold of himself, results in his demise. Another idea may be that Othello's disappointment with love results in his demise. On paper the two were well suited, both glamorous; he a highly regarded man of War and she a beauty beyond compare. However, as is obvious when we read the prose, the marriage is ill fated, with the two not really understanding the other's intentions or personalities. Indeed, Kenneth Muir writes that Desdemona fell in love 'with his autobiography rather than him'

Another take on the question may be that rather than his demise being self inflicted, it was actually a direct result of Iago's manipulation. The cast, at the beginning of the piece are absolute in their trust of Iago- which we can see through the monosyllabic, decisive use of language used in reference to him; ''Honest Iago...O brave Iago'. However, his manipulative ways soon came to the surface. A good example of commentary to put here would be EAJ Honningmann's statement- ''Pretending honesty and good will, he persuades others to accept his version of events'. This manipulation is fundamentally evil and drives Othello into such a rage that he acts out the murder as a result. Indeed, Coleridge said once that Iago was 'a being next to the devil'. This idea of Iago being evil can be found in Shakespeare's prose- 'Hell and night/ must bring this monstrous birth to the world's light'. We must now bring in some ideas about context- one idea may be to bring in some facts about witchcraft at the time- which was a prevalent fear! 

The last aspect of the answer to the question revolves around the idea that Othello and Desdemina had an ill fated relationship from the start and was doomed to fail, no matter what either of them did. At the time, society was still very racist, and so a relationship between two different races would have been viewed as suspicious. Throughout the play, Othello's African descent is exaggerated- 'Lascivious Moor'. While on the other hand, Desdemona's fragility and tenderness and also exaggerated- 'So tender, fair and happy'. Indeed, Dr Johnson, a critic of the time, claimed that the play was ' a useful moral not to make an unequal match'. Again, you must now talk about context, and racism at the time. 

So, in answer to the question we have discussed that perhaps Othello's demise was not as a result of his own failings but rather a multitude of problems. But remember, the only way to get those top marks is to include bits of commentary and context! It's all very easy to find; historical facts online or jStor, I have a large library of useful contextual stuff and critical commentary which you are more than welcome to use!

Rose N. A Level Religious Studies tutor, GCSE Religious Studies tutor...

2 years ago

Answered by Rose, an A Level English Literature tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

92 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£26 /hr

Mary C.

Degree: Sociolinguistics (Masters) - York University

Subjects offered:English Literature, English Language+ 1 more

English Literature
English Language

“During my undergraduate studies, I worked as a peer tutor for 2.5 years. I am currently preparing for my PhD applications.”

£26 /hr

Jemima H.

Degree: Mst Literature and Arts (Masters) - Oxford, Harris Manchester College University

Subjects offered:English Literature, Government and Politics+ 4 more

English Literature
Government and Politics
French
English
-Personal Statements-
-Oxbridge Preparation-

“I'm a masters student with teaching experience hoping to use my academic experience and knowledge to help students achieve their goals. ”

£20 /hr

Charlotte C.

Degree: Philosophy and English (Bachelors) - Southampton University

Subjects offered:English Literature, Religious Studies+ 3 more

English Literature
Religious Studies
Philosophy and Ethics
Extended Project Qualification
English Language

“I've overcome huge learning barriers over the years, and I want to help others do the same. Nobody should be written off.”

MyTutor guarantee

|  6 completed tutorials

About the author

£20 /hr

Rose N.

Degree: Theology (Bachelors) - Bristol University

Subjects offered:English Literature, Religious Studies+ 2 more

English Literature
Religious Studies
History
Geography

“Top tutor from the renowned Russell university group, ready to help you improve your grades.”

MyTutor guarantee

You may also like...

Posts by Rose

Explain Calvin's understanding of Knowledge

To what extent can Othello's ending be described as 'self inflicted'?

What did Aristotle mean by the 'Final Cause'?

What does Plato's Cave analogy in the 'Republic' tell us about his understanding of reality?

Other A Level English Literature questions

How is love characterised in William Shakespeare's Sonnet 116?

How do I use context effectively within an essay?

Compare and contrast the thoughts, themes and ideas presented in Grace Nichols' "Beauty" and Carol Ann Duffy's "The Diet"

How do I prepare for a closed-book exam?

View A Level English Literature tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok