Could we have nationalism without nation-states?

Before we can decide if nationalism can exist without nation-states, it is important to first clarify and define what we mean by 'nationalism' and 'nation-states'. Nationalism refers to the cultural similarities between its adherents and, simulatenously, creates a separation between the community and those perceived as 'others.' It derives much of its power from the nation-state and asserts that cultural boundaries should be coterminous with cultural bounderies. Nationalist groups make political demands; demands for control of a nation-state. A nation-state is a territorially defined, sovereign entity made up of citizens who are united by common traits, such as language or culture. While nationalism is connected to the nation-state in its political aspirations, it is possible for nationalism and nationalist movements to exist without nation-states. 

The Kurdish struggle for a nation-state is an example of a nationalist movement that is not connected to an existing state. Kurds live in Syria, Turkey, Iran, and Iraq. They claim a common identity and culture and their goal is the creation of a Kurdish nation-state. In this way, Kurdish nationalism can exist without a nation-state - the nation-state is the goal. Irish Nationalists seek a re-unified 32 county Ireland and object to the partition of the island in 1921. Nationalists see themselves as united by a common culture, shared use of the Irish language, and a shared struggle for the reunification of their nation-state. Nationalism can exist without a nation-state, however, a nation-state depends upon nationalism to unite its citizens in a shared identity and cause. 

AA
Answered by Allison A. Politics tutor

7293 Views

See similar Politics A Level tutors

Related Politics A Level answers

All answers ▸

Is perfect competition always a more desirable market structure than a monopoly?


What's the best way to revise for my exams?


How far are modern liberals willing to go in endorsing social and economic intervention?


Consider the view that conservatism is opposed to equality


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

MyTutor is part of the IXL family of brands:

© 2025 by IXL Learning