Explain the difference between analytic and ontological reduction

The difference concerns what is being reduced. Analytic reduction concerns concepts and language whereas ontological reduction concerns the nature of beings/ existence. Analytic reduction involves showing that the language of one term can be reduced or broken down into the language of another term without loss of meaning. For example, the term “bachelors” can be reduced to “unmarried men” without loss of meaning making the terms analytically reducible to each other. It is not possible to negate that they are the same in meaning without logical contradiction. Ontological reduction involves showing that beings or entities of one kind are in reality, the same as entities in another kind. Thus they are numerically identical and share the same spatial and time qualities. For example, although the morning star and evening star refer to two different concepts, they are the same entity – the same star.

AB

Related Philosophy A Level answers

All answers ▸

Outline Jackson's Mary Knowledge Argument [5 MARKS]


'The fact that I can conceive of a mind as existing separately to a body is enough to prove that the mind and body are distinct substances’ 25 marks


What does Decartes mean with his statement 'I think therefore I am'?


How does Aquinas use the idea of change to show that God exists?