705 views

### Why is (-1)*(-1)=1?

Even though this question seems trivial to most people with some mathematical expertise, it actually cuts quite deep into an intuitive understanding of what multiplication truly is. When one writes an expression like "5*2=10" what they really mean is that if I take two piles of 5 apples (or 5 piles of 2 apples) I get a total of 10 apples, but sadly this intuitive approach doesn't really generalize well to negative numbers. What does it mean to take (-1) of some object? To intuitively understand what multiplication is a different approach is required. Imagine I take a meter-stick with length 5 and scale it by a factor of 2. I clearly get a new meter-stick that has a length of 10. I could also scale it by something like a factor of pi and get another meter-stick with some length, so clearly this approach doesn't rely on the fact that the number is an intiger. In this case multiplication by a negative number would simply reverse the direction of the meter stick. If it was initially pointing to the right (the positive number direction), after multiplying it by -1 it would simply point in the opposite direction. Multiplying by -2 would just be a combination of two operations: first of all we would scale the meter stick by a factor of 2 and follow the scaling by an inversion. So, clearly, if we start with the number -1, which is simply a meter-stick of length one in the negative direction, and multiply it by -1, we invert it and get a meter-stick in the positive direction, which also has length 1. Hence (-1)*(-1)=1

2 years ago

Answered by Rudolfs, an IB Maths tutor with MyTutor

## Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

#### 38 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£20 /hr

Degree: MSc Financial Analysis and Fund Management (Masters) - Exeter University

Subjects offered:Maths, Economics

Maths
Economics

£20 /hr

Degree: Physics and Philosophy (Integrated Masters) - Kings, London University

Subjects offered:Maths, Physics+ 3 more

Maths
Physics
Philosophy and Ethics
-Personal Statements-

“I will teach my tutees to become expert problem solvers so that they can adapt to the requirements of any future examination.”

MyTutor guarantee

|  2 completed tutorials

£20 /hr

Degree: Mathematics (Bachelors) - Bath University

Subjects offered:Maths, Further Mathematics

Maths
Further Mathematics

“Hi, I’m Sachin and I study Maths at the University of Bath. I’m looking forward to working with my students to enable them to reach their highest potential.”

Currently unavailable: for regular students

Degree: Physics with Theoretical Physics (Masters) - Manchester University

Subjects offered:Maths, Physics

Maths
Physics

“I am a theoretical physics student at the University of Manchester. Even though I'm only in my first year I've had a lot of interaction with science already. I have participated and obtained medals in the International Physics Olympia...”

### You may also like...

#### Other IB Maths questions

write log2(5) +log2​​​​​​​(3) in its simplest form

Differentiate y = e^(x^2 - 3x).

When do you use 'n choose k' and where does the formula come from?

When the polynomial 3x^3 +ax+ b is divided by x−2 , the remainder is 2, and when divided by x +1 , it is 5. Find the value of a and the value of b.

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this.