MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

842 views

How do I answer a question where I am asked to compare or analyse sources?

Both Comparative and analystic source questions are difficult to approach if you have not been taught exactly how the exam boards like them answered.

In my experience, there is a relatively simple process that applies to all source-based questions, including questions asking you to compare two sources.

To begin with, you must gather the basic information from each source. When first reading the sources, note down these four things:

Content- what does the source actually say? While it seems simple, the first marks you willl get are from drawing out some of the basic information that is contained in each source. Examples include what events they are talking about, people mentioned and their actions etc. Once you have noted this information down, try and find similarities and differences between the two sources you are comparing.

Context- Next up is context. For this, you must bring in any historical knowledge not in the source to expand your argument. This includes who the author was and where they were from (its provenance), and why it was written (the purpose). Note these down and include any reasons you think the purpose of the source could help explain what is written, e.g. is it intended to persuade people to think in a certain way? Is it intended to distort the truth? Again, after you have looked at both sources, you should note down whether there are significant differences or similarities between the two sources

Significance- Once you have looked at the content and context of the sources, you must bring together what you have found out so far and decide which bits are significant. For example, does the fact that author was writing at the time mean that he or she is a more reliable source? Is the fact that they fought on one side in the conflict they are writing about mean their work contains bias? This is especially important in straight-up analysis questions, however should definitely be used when comparing sources too. At this point in a comparative essay, you should compare the content and context of both sources together, mentioning which is probably more reliable and any other relevant features of the context which help explain what is said in the content.

Cross-reference- This is absolutely vital to gain the highest marks. At this point, you need to cross reference the source you are analysing with all the other sources in the paper to see whether the back up what is said. In a comparative essay, you need to use information from other sources to prove which source is more accurate or reliable, as in these questions, they will often choose sources that show opposing view points. In addition to using the other sources in the paper, you must use your own knowledge to cross-reference what the sources say. This should include relevant dates, facts and statistics that support or oppose what the sources say and help you decide its accuracy and reliablilty. The top band of marks are reserved for those who pick up on the most complex details of the sources and then use their own knowledge to analyse these points further.

To conclude, once you have done these four steps, you should have analysed the source pretty thoroughly and if you can include the most relevant and interesting points and comparisons you discovered, then you should be able to get a solid mark. Remember, these four steps are to be used in the planning stage and you SHOULD NOT structure your argument with a paragraph on each stage. Your actual essay should be structured with the information you gathered at each stage integrated into a well-written argument. Therefore, when analysing sources always remember: Content, Context, Significance, Cross-reference.

Joseph W. A Level Classical Civilisation tutor, GCSE Classical Civili...

1 year ago

Answered by Joseph, a GCSE History tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

204 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£30 /hr

Edward H.

Degree: Philosophy (Bachelors) - Cambridge University

Subjects offered:History, Spanish+ 5 more

History
Spanish
Philosophy
French
English
-Personal Statements-
-Oxbridge Preparation-

“I'm Edward, and I tutor in Philosophy and Oxbridge preparation. I recently graduated from the University of Cambridge with a Double-First degree in Philosophy.”

Jack M. GCSE English tutor, 13 plus  English tutor, GCSE Government a...
£18 /hr

Jack M.

Degree: History and Ancient History (Bachelors) - Exeter University

Subjects offered:History, Government and Politics+ 1 more

History
Government and Politics
English

“I am a History and Ancient History student at the University of Exeter. I love my History degree but I am also passionate abouta English and Politics (the latter of which I achieved the highest mark in Europe for at edexcell A level)....”

£30 /hr

Megan T.

Degree: English (Bachelors) - Exeter University

Subjects offered:History, English Literature+ 1 more

History
English Literature

“I have always loved reading and analysying texts, so I am excited to inspire you, too. ”

About the author

£20 /hr

Joseph W.

Degree: Ancient, Medieval and Modern History (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered:History, Classical Civilisation

History
Classical Civilisation

“About Me: Hi! I am a student at Durham University studying Ancient, Medieval and Modern History. History is absolutely fascinating to me and my degree covers a vast array of historical periods, meaning I have agood grasp of the majori...”

You may also like...

Other GCSE History questions

Why did Clemenceau want a harsh treaty of Versailles in 1919?

How do I write a comparison essay?

How should I go about explaining how reliable a source is?

How was Hitler able to rise to power by 1933?

View GCSE History tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok