MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

461 views

What is the passive in French and how does it work?

The Passive, as in English is one of the three grammatical voices and is used to say that something is 'being done by somebody else'. In grammatical speak, we would say that the action that's described by the verb (eating, organising or whatever) is being done to the subject by an agent.

For instance: if we said in the active voice: 'the students are organising a party', in the passive voice, this would become 'a party is being organised by the students'. The verb with the action is organise, the subject is the party and the agent is the 'students'.

Just like with the active voice (where the subject of the verb actually does the action) it is available in all tenses - in the indicative and in the subjunctive.

A preposition is usually required and this is either par or de.

So, how does it work?

1) Move the direct object of the verb into the place of the subject.

2) Replace the verb form with the appropriate tense of etre + a past participle.

Now, this être must be in the same tense as the original main verb. Also, the past participle needs to agree in gender and number with the subject- like in any etre past tense verb.

Preposition wise: DE when we have a vague, indeterminate or habitual relationship- for instance: ....les legumes suivi de tiramisu

PAR when we have a specific, definite, or unusal relationship:

..Paul a été battu par Bob.

So, let's have a look at an example:

Les étudiants organisent une fête.

1) Move 'une fête' to the begining of the sentence.

2) The main verb, organisent' is in the present indicative, so we need to use the present indicative of etre in the passive sentence. In this case, we need 'est'

3) Agreements: fête is feminine so, our past participle must agree: 'organisée'

4) Preposition: par - this is a specific thing

Altogether: Une fête est organisée par les étudiants.

But, one important thing, Only the direct object of a verb can become a subject of a passive. INDIRECT OBJECTS CAN'T. Therefore, verbs that take an indirect object cannot be used in the passive voice.

So, for instance, 'demander x à quelqu'un' - this takes an indirect object, so the verb 'demander' can't be used in the passive voice.

Some other common examples include:

apprendre qc à qn: to teach somebody something

conseiller qc à qn: to advise somebody to do something

donner qc à qn: to give somebody something

But, ok, now we have seen the rules, why do we need it?

Basically just for stylistic purposes:

- To emphasise the sufferer of the action instead of the agent.

-As an alternative to 'on' when we don't know who did something- such as in police reports.

-Certain verbs + de to express descriptions: Le panier etait rempli de fraises.

- Certain verbs + de to express feelings, attitudes, and states of knowledge. Eg: Elle étatit connue de tout le quartier (we use de here because 'quartier' is quite vague and we don't know exactly who knows her).

But, when we have one of those verbs which cannot be used in the Passive, (verbs which are followed by an indirect object), it is important to be aware that it can be avoided.

There are many ways to avoid the passive, but, we shall focus on two for the moment and of those the safest by far is by using ON:

eg: On demande à Bob de partir.

Se voir + an Infinitive is also an option: Il s'est vu refuser: he was refused

To sum up, don't worry about the passive, just remember to make your past participles agree and don't use it with indirect objects!

Charlotte S. GCSE Biology tutor, GCSE French tutor, A Level French tu...

11 months ago

Answered by Charlotte, an A Level French tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

98 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£20 /hr

Roxanne B.

Degree: International Relations and Politics (Bachelors) - Sheffield University

Subjects offered:French

French

“I am a French native, passionate about my language and its beauty, ready to help you speak it à la perfection.  I am currently studying International Relations and Politics in Sheffield. Before this year, I was in high school in Franc...”

£20 /hr

Rini J.

Degree: Philosophy and Modern Languages (Bachelors) - Oxford, St Hilda's College University

Subjects offered:French, Religious Studies+ 6 more

French
Religious Studies
Philosophy
English and World Literature
English Literature
English Language
-Personal Statements-

“An Oxford student and aspiring teacher with extensive tutoring experience in the UK, France, and China. ”

£30 /hr

Amee T.

Degree: BA Modern Languages - French and Arabic (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered:French, Music+ 1 more

French
Music
Arabic

“Amee Thwaites, 2nd year student at Durham University, experienced and enthusiastic tutor of Music, French and English!”

About the author

£20 /hr

Charlotte S.

Degree: Modern Languages with a Year Abroad (French and Italian) (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered:French, Maths+ 4 more

French
Maths
Extended Project Qualification
Biology
.MLAT (Modern Languages)
-Personal Statements-

“I'm a modern languages student studying French and Italian at Durham University . I have ahuge passion for languages and absolutely love anything French or Italian related- from road signs to medieval French literature; I am mesmerised ...”

You may also like...

Posts by Charlotte

In the perfect tense, when should I use Avere and when should I use Essere?

What are possessive adjectives in Italian and how to I use them?

What is the passive in French and how does it work?

Other A Level French questions

Y and En

How and when do I use the French past historic?

What is the difference between direct and indirect object pronouns?

How do I know if verbs take "avoir" or "être"?

View A Level French tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok