MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

208 views

Why does the verb "haber" sometimes not match the person and number of the subject in a sentence?

The main uses of the verb "haber" include its use as an auxilliary verb (ha comido) and as part of a verbal periphrasis (he de soportar), in this case, the person (first, second or third person) and number (singular, plural) do match those of the subject in a sentence.

However, one of the most important uses of this verb is in its impersonal form. This means that "haber" in its impersonal form appears in sentences that do not have a "person" or object as a subject. For example in "Hay una té en la mesa", one may think that "té" is the subject when in reality it is a direct object. In another example, "Hubo varios voluntarios en la sala", it might appear more confusing, as one might think that the subject would be "varios voluntarios", which is in plural.

One way to make sure whether the verb we are working with is impersonal or not is to attempt replacing the apparent subject with a direct object pronoun (lo, la, los, las) and a subject pronoun (él, ella, ellos, ellas), and check with which one is the sentence coherent. In the sentence "Hay té en la mesa":

Él hay en la mesa (as subject)

Lo hay en la mesa (as direct object)

As we can see above, the first sentence is not coherent as a "person" or object cannot perform the action of the conjugated verb "hay". Therefore, the second sentence proves that the verb "haber" in this case functions as impersonal.

Hui Z. IB Spanish tutor, GCSE Spanish tutor, A Level Spanish tutor, I...

5 months ago

Answered by Hui, an A Level Spanish tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

82 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£22 /hr

Jill M.

Degree: Modern Languages and Cultures (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered:Spanish, Maths+ 2 more

Spanish
Maths
History
French

“I'm in my second year at Durham University studying French and Spanish. I love languages and am eager to help you with your French or Spanish studies in any way that I can!”

£22 /hr

Emma H.

Degree: MA Transnational Studies (Masters) - Southampton University

Subjects offered:Spanish, German+ 1 more

Spanish
German
French

“Hi there! My name is Emma and I am currently doing a masters at the University of Southampton. My Bachelor's degree was French, Spanish and German and I have lived in all three countries. I worked as an au pair in Spain and privately...”

£20 /hr

Zahra S.

Degree: Modern and Medieval Languages (Bachelors) - Cambridge University

Subjects offered:Spanish, Italian+ 3 more

Spanish
Italian
French
-Personal Statements-
-Oxbridge Preparation-

“¡Hola! Ciao! Salut! I'm Zahra and I'm currently in my first year studying French and Spanish at the University of Cambridge. ”

About the author

Hui Z.

Currently unavailable: for regular students

Degree: Biomedical Science (Bachelors) - Kings, London University

Subjects offered:Spanish, Biology

Spanish
Biology

“About me My name is Hui and I am a Biomedical Science student at King's College London. I was born in Alicante, Spain so I speak native Spanish and since I was young I developed an interest for languages (for sciences too!). I believe...”

MyTutor guarantee

You may also like...

Other A Level Spanish questions

Which adjectives do not take the subjunctive in the construction "Es (adjective) que..."

When do you use the personal a?

Do you want to make a difference in your exam? Then let me introduce you to: “los hiatos y diptongos”

How can I improve my essay terminology?

View A Level Spanish tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok