MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

924 views

What is the ‘is-ought’ fallacy?

The ‘is-ought’ fallacy, associated most notably with David Hume, is a fallacy committed in reasoning from descriptive premises to normative or prescriptive conclusions. Descriptive statements describe things: they tell us how the world is (and as such typically contain an ‘is’). However, normative or prescriptive statements tell us how the world ought to be (and as such typically contain as ‘ought’). Reflect for a moment on this argument: (1) either that flying object is a bird or it is a plane; (2) that flying object is not a bird; therefore, (3) that flying object is a plane. This argument is what logicians call valid because the premises entail the conclusion. In other words, so long as the premises are true it’s impossible for the conclusion to be false. Compare this kind of argument: (1) Evolution is a competition for survival; (2) we humans are the products of evolution; therefore, (3) we humans ought to compete to survive. Is this argument valid? It may appear to have some initial plausibility, but it doesn’t seem at all obvious that it is. From the fact that evolution is a competition for survival and the fact that humans are the result of evolution, it doesn’t follow that humans ought to compete to survive. All that really follows is that so far we have - successfully - competed for survival. It’s important to note that that’s not to say that humans ought not to compete to survive, only that these facts alone do not establish any conclusion about what ought to happen whatsoever. This kind of fallacy is often committed by so-called Social Darwinists, who believe that evolutionary theory has implications for how we ought to arrange society or live our lives.

Luke N. A Level Philosophy tutor, GCSE Philosophy tutor, IB Philosoph...

2 years ago

Answered by Luke, an A Level Philosophy tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

23 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£22 /hr

Noah C.

Degree: PPE (Bachelors) - Oxford, Magdalen College University

Subjects offered:Philosophy, Politics+ 4 more

Philosophy
Politics
Maths
Further Mathematics
Economics
.TSA. Oxford.

“Hi, I'm Noah. I'm currrently studying Politics, Philosophy and Economics (PPE) at Oxford university. I have always enjoyed teaching others and helping them learn, and my first experience with tutoring was several years of teaching str...”

£20 /hr

Max W.

Degree: Master of Arts in Philosphy and Theology (Bachelors) - St. Andrews University

Subjects offered:Philosophy, Religious Studies+ 3 more

Philosophy
Religious Studies
Philosophy and Ethics
Extended Project Qualification
-Personal Statements-

“So you need help with philosophy or religious studies? Do not fear - you are studying the most influential subject in the history of the planet - its not easy but its still amazing! I am a Philosophy and Theology student at the Univer...”

£20 /hr

Alexander P.

Degree: Philosophy (Masters) - Durham University

Subjects offered:Philosophy, Classical Civilisation+ 1 more

Philosophy
Classical Civilisation
-Personal Statements-

“I am a graduate in Classics and Philosophy, studying for a Philosophy MA. I have great enthusiasm for both subjects, and hope to pass on some of this passion!”

About the author

Luke N.

Currently unavailable: for regular students

Degree: Philosophy (Bachelors) - Glasgow University

Subjects offered:Philosophy, Politics

Philosophy
Politics

“First-class Hons Philosophy graduate, about to embark on post-graduate study: care deeply about my subject and keen to help”

You may also like...

Posts by Luke

What is the ‘hard problem’ of consciousness?

What is the ‘is-ought’ fallacy?

Why might moral reasoning be a problem for moral non-cognitivism?

Other A Level Philosophy questions

Explain Paley’s Teleological Argument

To what extent (if any) do your preconceived ideas affect what you see? Is this a problem for foundationalism?

Explain and illustrate two reasons for holding the view that at birth the mind is a tabula rasa (blank slate). [15 marks]

What is Functionalism in the Philosophy of Mind?

View A Level Philosophy tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok