Why is the nuclear model better than the plum pudding model of the atom?

The plum pudding model was the idea of a positively charged sphere, with negative electrons dotted within it as the model of an atom. easiest understood drawn outA scientist named Rutherford did an experiment firiring positively charged alpha particles to a very thin sheet of gold, as close to 1 atom thin as possible. The experiment found that most alpha particles went straight through the gold without anything happening to them, only a small amount were deflected at big angles and an even smaller amount were backscattered. again, best being drawn out. The conclusions from this were that a very very small part of the atom must be positive, and that part must be concentrated in the centre due to the large angles. Also, most of the atom must have been empty space, as most of the alpha particles weren't affected. The plum pudding model was far from this, and so the new current nuclear model was formed from the results of this experiment. draw out nuclear model So in summary:plum pudding model was a positive sphere with small negative electrons, and mass and charge spread equally throughoutthe Rutherford experiment found most alpha particles passed straight through thin gold foil, some at large angles and some were backscattered this meant most of the atom must be empty space, with a small concentrated positive central nucleus hence the nuclear model was created

GH
Answered by Georgina H. Physics tutor

20782 Views

See similar Physics GCSE tutors

Related Physics GCSE answers

All answers ▸

What is terminal velocity and what causes it?


A 70Kg person jumps out of a plane and deploys a parachute, once the parachute is open the wind resistance acting on the person and the parachute is 900N. What is the direction and magnitude of the persons acceleration.


A ball of mass 500g is dropped from rest 2m above the ground. When it reaches the ground it is travelling at 5m/s. How much energy has been dissipated?


Describe the model now used for the structure of an atom. Refer to the constituent particles including their relative masses and charges.


We're here to help

contact us iconContact ustelephone icon+44 (0) 203 773 6020
Facebook logoInstagram logoLinkedIn logo

MyTutor is part of the IXL family of brands:

© 2026 by IXL Learning