Explain the difference between Lamarck’s and Darwin’s theory of evolution? Why was Darwin’s more successful?

Darwin and Lamarck were both scientists who tried to understand evolution. 

Lamarck’s theory of evolution was based around how organisms (e.g. animals, plants) change during their lifetime, and then pass these changes onto their offspring. For example, Lamarck believes that the giraffe had a long neck because its neck grew longer during its lifetime, as it stretched to reach leaves in high-up trees, meaning that each generation of giraffe had a longer neck than previous generations. 

Darwin’s theory, known as natural selection, believed that organisms possessed variation (each individual was slightly different from one another), and these variations led to some being more likely to survive and reproduce than others. Features that made an organism more likely to survive or reproduce are therefore more likely to appear to each generation. In terms of the giraffe, Darwin’s theory would state that longer necked giraffes were more likely to survive, because they could eat leaves from taller trees, and therefore more long-necked giraffes will be born, which eventually caused all giraffes to have longer necks. Longer necked giraffes survived because they were a better fit for their environment. It is from this idea that we get the phrase ‘survival of the fittest’.

Darwin’s theory became accepted because it had more evidence that supported it. Lamarck’s theory suggest that all organisms become more complicated over time, and therefore doesn’t account for simple organisms, such as single-cell organisms. We also know through observation that characteristics inherited during an individual’s lifetime do not get passed onto their offspring; for example, if someone pierces their ear, it doesn’t mean that their children will be born with pierced ears. Darwin’s theory became even stronger when, many years after his death, the study of genetics emerged. Genetics ultimately showed that all inherited traits were passed on through genes, which are unaffected by outside world, as Lamarck would predict, and are instead naturally varied, as Darwin predicted. Though Darwin didn’t know what genes were, he could see their effect on natural selection.  

Ted H. GCSE History tutor, A Level History tutor, A Level Government ...

11 months ago

Answered by Ted, a GCSE Biology tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist


PremiumKarolina K. Mentoring -Medical School Preparation- tutor, GCSE Biolog...
View profile
£22 /hr

Karolina K.

Degree: Dentistry (Bachelors) - Kings, London University

Subjects offered: Biology, Science+ 5 more

-Personal Statements-
-Medical School Preparation-

“Hi, my name is Karolina and I am a Dentistry Student from King's College London.  I understand that many students find certain aspects of the A-level syllabus challenging and having recently completed mine I believe that I know how to...”

PremiumRoslyn I. GCSE English tutor, GCSE Biology tutor, A Level Extended Pr...
View profile
£22 /hr

Roslyn I.

Degree: Anthropology with International Relations (Bachelors) - Exeter University

Subjects offered: Biology, Extended Project Qualification+ 2 more

Extended Project Qualification
-Personal Statements-

“My name is Roslyn Irving and I am currently studying for a degree in Anthropology and International Relations. Having taken Science A-levels as well as English I am in a good position to ”

Fabiha A. GCSE Biology tutor, A Level Biology tutor, GCSE Chemistry t...
View profile
£18 /hr

Fabiha A.

Degree: Biomedical Science (Bachelors) - Kings, London University

Subjects offered: Biology, Science+ 1 more


“About me I am currently studying Biomedical Science at King's College London because it combines my twomost loved subjects, Biology and Chemistry. My enthusiasm for all things science make me want to keep learning and also use my kno...”

About the author

PremiumTed H. GCSE History tutor, A Level History tutor, A Level Government ...
View profile

Ted H.

Currently unavailable: for regular students

Degree: Archaeology and Anthropology (Bachelors) - Cambridge alumni University

Subjects offered: Biology, Spanish+ 2 more

Government and Politics

“Academic RecordI have just graduated from Cambridge University, with a 2.1 in Archaeology and Anthropology, focusing mainly on biological anthropology (how humans fit into biology as a whole). At A-Level I took History, Politics, Spa...”

You may also like...

Other GCSE Biology questions

Name two structural differences between arteries and veins.

Why is it important to regulate body temperature? What is the role of our skin in regulating our body temperature?

Why are enzymes less efficient at temperatures lower than body temperature?

What is a phagocyte?

View GCSE Biology tutors


We use cookies to improve our service. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss