There are three boxes and one has a prize inside. You are told to choose a box. One of the other boxes is then opened, showing that it is empty. You are given the option to switch your choice to the other remaining box. Should you switch? Why?

MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

Answers / Maths / GCSE / There are three boxes and one has a prize inside. You are told to choose a box. One of the other boxes is then opened, showing that it is empty. You are given the option to switch your choice to the other remaining box. Should you switch? Why?

631 views

There are three boxes and one has a prize inside. You are told to choose a box. One of the other boxes is then opened, showing that it is empty. You are given the option to switch your choice to the other remaining box. Should you switch? Why?

Let's think of the three boxes as A, B and C.
Say we choose box A.
There is a 1 in 3 chance that our box has the prize inside, and so a 2 in 3 chance that it does not.
When a box is opened and shown to be empty, this DOES NOT leave us with a 50/50 chance of choosing the prize box when given the choice of switching.
We started with a 2 in 3 chance of having not chosen correctly, and so we have a 2 in 3 chance of the switch being a good choice, as it will take us to the box with the prize, since that is the only remaining box. This means that the best choice is to switch our box.

David A. A Level Physics tutor, GCSE Physics tutor, A Level Maths tut...

1 year ago

Answered by David, a GCSE Maths tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

780 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

Mark H. GCSE Maths tutor, A Level Maths tutor, GCSE Physics tutor

View profile

£24 /hr

Mark H.

Degree: Mathematics MMath (Masters) - Manchester University

Subjects offered:Maths, Physics+ 1 more

“Hello there, I'm Mark and I study Mathematics at the University of Manchester! Let me help you achieve your best!”

5.0

74 reviews | 113 completed tutorials

Save profile

Pankaj K. A Level Physics tutor, GCSE Physics tutor, A Level Maths tu...

View profile

£18 /hr

Pankaj K.

Degree: Physics (Bachelors) - Kings, London University

Subjects offered:Maths, Physics+ 1 more

“Positive, Dedicated, Motivating, Calm, Patient, Understanding, Professional, Organised, Experienced, Focused, Enthusiastic, Passionate”

MyTutor guarantee

| 1 completed tutorial

Save profile

Kamil F. A Level Further Mathematics tutor, GCSE Further Mathematics...

View profile

£18 /hr

Kamil F.

Degree: Mechanical Engineering (Masters) - Manchester University

Subjects offered:Maths, Physics+ 2 more

“"It is the supreme art of the teacher to awaken joy in creative expression and knowledge." Albert Einstein”

4.8

8 reviews | 6 completed tutorials

Save profile

See more GCSE Maths tutors

About the author

View profile

£18 /hr

David A.

Degree: Medical Physics MSci (Masters) - University College London University

Subjects offered:Maths, Physics+ 1 more

“About me I have just finished my final exams for my masters year of my Medical Physics MSci at UCL, and I am looking forward to starting training in the NHS as a medical physicist! Tutoring I have plenty of spare time and energy this ...”

MyTutor guarantee

Save profile

Version:	3.49.9
Build:	5f485a18d000
Time:	2017-09-20T16:11:15Z

MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

There are three boxes and one has a prize inside. You are told to choose a box. One of the other boxes is then opened, showing that it is empty. You are given the option to switch your choice to the other remaining box. Should you switch? Why?

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

780 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

About the author

You may also like...

Posts by David

Other GCSE Maths questions

One-to-one help is at your fingertips