MYTUTOR SUBJECT ANSWERS

195 views

Why did people join the First Crusade?

The easiest way to split this question is by factor: economic/material gain, religious devotion, legal reasons, social reasons. In terms of historians, the more outdated view was that economic reasons were more important but the modern viewpoint is that people joined for religious reasons. You can choose which ever factor you want as the most important as your essay though.

This is obviously a very cut down and brief summary so your actual essay should include more detail and analysis as well as understanding of the topic. I would recommend organising a tutorial to go over this essay so I can explain points in more detail for better understanding!

Summary of key points to include: 

Religious devotion

Spiritual

(Modern view – Asbridge)

. Riley-Smith and Bull  à evidence from the Charters – people sold everything.

. Raymond sold everything and took his whole family

. Appeal of Jerusalem e.g. Jesus and Holy Sepulchre

. Godfrey of Bouillon took monks with him

. Bertrand of Moncontour gave up monastic lands  he illegally owned so his soul was pure

Social 

. Feudal system à chain reaction after nobility joined e.g. Count Raymond of Toulouse was  the first Prince to join at Clermont.

.  Violence of knights à  was permitted on crusade, desirable.

. Family history of  pilgrimageà Count Robert II of Flanders’ dad had developed links with Alexios I on pilgrimage in 1089 and Rob felt he should carry that on

Political 

To escape legal proceedings in the West e.g. interest on debts was cancelled.

. Count Hugh of Vermandois was the King of France’s (Philip I) brother who had fallen out with the Pope (committed adultery) so Hugh went to show the Kings willing

. Duke Robert  of Normandy was the brother of William II of England who wanted to see him go and so raised a special tax in England to allow this.

Economic/material gain

(Traditional view)

. Personal advancement à Bohemond of Taranto was a second son and had failed to gain lands in the Balkan invasion with his father in the 1080s. He left crusade at Antioch. “Stand fast all together, trusting in Christ and the victory of the cross because today, please God, you will all gain much booty.”

. Soldiers received a wage à could collect booty “But not to excess” (Pope)

. Drought and poor harvest (1090s) à  nothing to lose. Pope: “land of milk and honey.”

Evidence it was not actually material gain:

Raymond of Toulouse was one of the richest secular Lords in France and a first born son

. Philips: Cost 4  x a knights annual income to go on crusade

. Plunder belonged to Lords  of which there where 200 out of 50-100 thousand crusaders

Lucy  L. GCSE History tutor, A Level History tutor, Mentoring -Person...

4 months ago

Answered by Lucy , an A Level History tutor with MyTutor


Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist

89 SUBJECT SPECIALISTS

£20 /hr

India J.

Degree: History and Archaeology (Bachelors) - Edinburgh University

Subjects offered:History, Latin+ 1 more

History
Latin
English Literature

“History, Classics and English tutor from Edinburgh University, ready to help you improve your grades and become more confident in your subject.”

MyTutor guarantee

£26 /hr

Chloe T.

Degree: History and Italian (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered:History, Italian+ 1 more

History
Italian
Art

“About Me:I am currently in my second year at Durham University studying two subjects I love:History and Italian.History:History has always been a great interest of mine. However, at A Level and GCSE the subject can present diffic...”

£20 /hr

Lucinda M.

Degree: History (Bachelors) - Bristol University

Subjects offered:History, Politics+ 2 more

History
Politics
English Literature

“I am a very enthusiastic, hard-working student. I always strive for success in my own grades and I will do the same for you to help you achieve your goals. ”

MyTutor guarantee

About the author

Lucy L.

Currently unavailable: for new students

Degree: History (Bachelors) - Exeter University

Subjects offered:History, -Personal Statements-

History
-Personal Statements-

“About me: I am currently a history student at Exeter University. I love the study of my subject and hope you will too! The most important part of my tutorials will be sharing this passion and making sure learning is as fun as possible...”

You may also like...

Posts by Lucy

What is the best way to structure an A level history exam essay question?

Why did people join the First Crusade?

Other A Level History questions

What role did Martin Luther King Jr. play in helping the rights of Black Americans?

Was Chamberlain's conference in Munich a triumph or diaster?

How should I read critically?

What tips would you give when revising for History exams?

View A Level History tutors

We use cookies to improve your site experience. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss

mtw:mercury1:status:ok