When using the addition rule in probability, why must we subtract the "intersection" to find the "union" with the Addition Rule?

There is a subtle point to be made here, which comes down to double counting. 

The addition rule:

Pr(A union B) = Pr(A)+Pr(B)-Pr(A intersection B)

allows us to work out the probability that either event A or event B happens: i.e., it tells us for any two events A and B, what is the probability that one of them occurs. 

However, this probability is affected by the relationship between the two events themselves. In particular, it matters whether the events are mutually exclusive or not.

Consider the following example:

A class of 20 students contains 12 boys and 8 pupils with blonde hair. What is the probability that a student is either a boy or has blonde hair?

Let event A be that a student is chosen with blonde hair and let event B be that a boy is chosen. Thus we are trying to find Pr(A union B) - what is the probability of event A or B occuring? The natural response is to think it is simply Pr(A) + Pr(B), in this case 8/20+12/20 =20/20=1

However, this is only true if there are no boys with blonde hair. Suppose instead that there are 2 boys with blonde hair in the class. Now the probability of choosing a student that is either a boy or blonde has fallen, since of the 8 remaining girls in the class, 2 do not have blonde hair. So we must calculate:

Pr(A union B) = Pr(A)+Pr(B)-Pr(A intersection B)

Here, Pr(A intersection B) is the probability that a student is a blonde boy, which is 2/20. Therefore, our new probability is:

Pr(A union B)=8/20+12/20-2/20=18/20

If we did not subtract the term at the end, we would be double counting the blonde haired boys firstly as boys and then as students with blonde hair, fogetting that they are one and the same individual in 2 cases. 

To make this point another way, consider a Venn diagram. With two mutually exclusive events, two circles in the Venn diagram do not overlap. With non-mutually excusive events, the circles do overlap. The overlap is the intersection, calculated here as 2/20. If we do not subtract this intersection from Pr(A) +Pr(B), we double count it, giving us the wrong probability of both events happening.

Lewis G. A Level Maths tutor, GCSE Maths tutor, A Level Economics tut...

1 year ago

Answered by Lewis, an A Level Maths tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist


PremiumKonrad E. GCSE Chemistry tutor, GCSE Biology tutor, A Level Chemistry...
View profile
£26 /hr

Konrad E.

Degree: Natural Sciences: Physical (Masters) - Cambridge University

Subjects offered: Maths, Physics+ 2 more

Further Mathematics

“I'm studying Natural Sciences (Phys) at Cambridge. I enjoy tutoring science and maths at GCSE and A-Level, and sharing my experience.”

Alex D. IB Maths tutor, 11 Plus Maths tutor, GCSE Maths tutor, A Leve...
View profile
£20 /hr

Alex D.

Degree: Chemical Engineering (Masters) - Edinburgh University

Subjects offered: Maths, Physics+ 1 more


“I have a lot of experience working with children as a young scout leader volunteering at the cubs for a year and a half as well as being a mentor to a primary 4 and a primary 7 class for a year. I also have a PVG Disclosure Scotland c...”

MyTutor guarantee

PremiumAdam B. A Level Economics tutor, GCSE Economics tutor, 11 Plus Maths ...
View profile
£30 /hr

Adam B.

Degree: Economics and Mathematics (Bachelors) - Bristol University

Subjects offered: Maths, Further Mathematics + 1 more

Further Mathematics

“Hi!  I'm an enthuthiastic and motivated tutor with a commitment to developing my student's understanding of concepts within their chosen subjects.  As an Economics and Mathematics undergraduate I am committed to delivering a tailored...”

About the author

PremiumLewis G. A Level Maths tutor, GCSE Maths tutor, A Level Economics tut...
View profile

Lewis G.

Currently unavailable: for new students

Degree: MPhil in Economics Research (Masters) - Cambridge University

Subjects offered: Maths, Economics


“About me: I'm currently a graduate economics student at Cambridge University. Before Cambridge, I was at Warwick University, where I read Philosophy, Politics and Economics, graduating with First Class honours and ranked joint 1st ove...”

You may also like...

Other A Level Maths questions

How do you use trigonometry to work out angles and lengths of sides in a right angle triangle

What are complex numbers?

How to factorise any quadratic expression

How do you intergrate ln(x)?

View A Level Maths tutors


We use cookies to improve our service. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss