Why did the Grand Alliance fail after WWII?

This type of question invites you to look at the causes of failure. This type of essay can be structured in two ways: either you posit two different reasons, examin them thorougherly (3 paras each) and decide which arguent is the stronger. This approach usually fits into questions where there is a clear historigogrpahical division. The other approach is that you assess the merits of a multitiude of reasons, and decide on the most persuaswive. 

This esssay could be strucutured either way. One side could aruge it was the USSRs fault, the other side could argue that it was the Wests fault. This would mean looking at all the reasons that the alliance fell, and placing them into one camp or another. This has the benefit of making historigography clear, and quoting opinunated historians such as Barrass and Overy. However, it might ommitt the fact that the collapse may have been nobodys 'fault' - and indeed the word 'fault' may be too simplistic a term that distracts from the question.

Therefore, a better apprach might be to deal with the various reasons in their turn, and quote historians along the way. Paragraphs might include: cnotrasting ideologies which led to inevitable hositlity, the mistrust of the 1930s, the situation during WWII (poland etc), importance of Stalin

It is important to use examples that stick within the date range the questions sets (eg. why did grand alliance fail by 1949) : depending on the phrasing of the question, the evidence you can use might be restircted, and your answer most be accordingly changed.

Depending on the phrasing of the question, it might also be possible to include coutner-arguments ( far to you agree that the reason for the failure of the alliance was 'x'). If that was the phrasing of the question, then after anaylising 'x' and the other factors which led to the failure of the grand alliance, it would show good understanding of the topic to include examples which suggest that the failure wasnt inevitable and could have survived (eg.Tehran confrence) (unifying economic policy of west)

If your conclusion is therefore a nuanced one (which tends to go down well) it is a good idea to indlude a historian that backs up your point - (ie) Tony Judt: the Grand Alliance was “just an interlude in an international struggle between the Western democracies and Soviet totalitarianism”.

Jack M. GCSE English tutor, 13 plus  English tutor, GCSE Government a...

7 months ago

Answered by Jack, an A Level History tutor with MyTutor

Still stuck? Get one-to-one help from a personally interviewed subject specialist


Sheridan G. A Level History tutor, 13 plus  History tutor, GCSE Histo...
View profile
£20 /hr

Sheridan G.

Degree: History and International Relations (Bachelors) - Exeter University

Subjects offered: History, English Literature+ 1 more

English Literature
-Personal Statements-

“I am a History and International Relations student at the University of Exeter. I have a real passion for both subjectsand would love to transfer some of this enthusiasm through my tutoring. Moreover, having also completedEnglish and D...”

MyTutor guarantee

PremiumIsabelle A. GCSE English Literature tutor, A Level English Literature...
View profile
£24 /hr

Isabelle A.

Degree: Combined Honours in Arts (English Literature, History and Spanish) (Bachelors) - Durham University

Subjects offered: History, Spanish+ 2 more

Extended Project Qualification
English Literature

“Hi, I’m Isabelle. About Me I’m a second-year student at Durham University studying modules in English, History and, in my first year, Spanish, for my Combined Honours in Arts degree. I’ve previously tutored A-Level English Literature...”

Charlotte  H. GCSE Geography tutor, GCSE History tutor, A Level Histo...
View profile
£20 /hr

Charlotte H.

Degree: History (Masters) - Edinburgh University

Subjects offered: History, Psychology+ 2 more

-Personal Statements-

“Hello! My name is Charlotte and I am a 3rd year History undergraduate at the University of Edinburgh. I finished my school career at Newcastle School for Girls with 2 A*'s and an A at A Level in History, Psychology and Geography. Comi...”

MyTutor guarantee

About the author

Jack M. GCSE English tutor, 13 plus  English tutor, GCSE Government a...
View profile
£20 /hr

Jack M.

Degree: History and Ancient History (Bachelors) - Exeter University

Subjects offered: History, Government and Politics+ 1 more

Government and Politics

“I am a History and Ancient History student at the University of Exeter. I love my History degree but I am also passionate abouta English and Politics (the latter of which I achieved the highest mark in Europe for at edexcell A level)....”

You may also like...

Posts by Jack

How do I analyse a source?

How do I memorise facts for History? (source too)

I don't know how to analyse a poem's language, form and structure!!!?

Why did the Grand Alliance fail after WWII?

Other A Level History questions

How do the standards of GCSE and A-level differ?

Why did the Romanov dynasty collapse in 1917?

What were the key motivations of Alexander III?

How significant was the Partition of India?

View A Level History tutors


We use cookies to improve our service. By continuing to use this website, we'll assume that you're OK with this. Dismiss